Did you like this answer?
👍 0
👎 0
# Step-by-Step Solution: Doubly Reinforced Beam Design
Given:
- **Concrete compressive strength:** \( f'_c = 500 \) psi
- **Steel yield strength:** \( f_y = 40,000 \) psi (both tension and compression)
- **Beam width:** \( b = 16 \) in
- **Overall thickness:** \( h = 30 \) in
- **Effective depth to tension steel:** \( d = 27 \) in
- **Effective depth to compression steel:** \( d' = 3 \) in
- **Compression steel:** 2 #9 bars in single layer
- **Ultimate moment:** \( M_u = 4,950,000 \) in-lb
- **Use #9 bars for tension steel**
Let's proceed step by step.
---
## 1. **Convert Units**
\[
M_u = 4,950,000~\text{in-lb} = \frac{4,950,000}{12} = 412,500~\text{ft-lb} = 4,950~\text{kip-in}
\]
But we'll keep it in in-lb since other dimensions are in inches.
---
## 2. **Area of #9 Bar**
Standard #9 bar area (\( A_b \)):
\[
A_b = 1.00~\text{in}^2 \quad \text{(from ACI Table)}
\]
---
## 3. **Area of Compression Reinforcement**
2 #9 bars:
\[
A_s' = 2 \times 1.00 = 2.00~\text{in}^2
\]
---
## 4. **Reduction Factor (\( \phi \))**
ACI 318 for flexure (tension-controlled) beams:
\[
\phi = .9
\]
---
## 5. **Calculate Factored Moment \( M_n \)**
\[
\phi M_n \ge M_u \implies M_n = \frac{M_u}{\phi} = \frac{4,950,000}{.9} = 5,500,000~\text{in-lb}
\]
---
## 6. **Check Limiting Moment for Singly Reinforced Beam**
Maximum singly reinforced moment:
\[
M_{n,\text{max}} = .90 \times A_{s,\text{max}} \times f_y \times (d - a/2)
\]
But let's use the classic limit for singly reinforced:
\[
M_{n,\text{max}} = .85 f'_c b a_{\text{max}} (d - a_{\text{max}}/2)
\]
Where \( a_{\text{max}} = \beta_1 c_{\text{max}} \), and \( c_{\text{max}} \) is the distance to the neutral axis at yield strain limit.
For \( f'_c = 500 \) psi:
\[
\beta_1 = .85 - .05 \left(\frac{f'_c - 400}{100}\right) = .85 - .05(1) = .80
\]
(Limit min .65, max .85)
For tension-controlled section (\( \varepsilon_t \ge .005 \)),
\( c_{\text{max}} = \frac{\varepsilon_{cu}}{\varepsilon_{cu} + \varepsilon_y}d \)
But for quick estimation, let’s assume singly reinforced capacity is not enough and proceed to doubly reinforced calculation.
---
## 7. **Force in Compression Steel (\( A_s' \))**
Assume compression steel yields:
\[
F_s' = A_s' f_y = 2.00 \times 40,000 = 80,000~\text{lb}
\]
---
## 8. **Assume Neutral Axis Depth, \( c \), and Compute \( a \)**
Let the total compressive force be:
\[
C = .85 f'_c b a + F_s'
\]
\[
T = A_s f_y
\]
\[
C = T
\]
Let’s denote \( a \) as the depth of equivalent rectangular stress block.
\[
T = .85 f'_c b a + A_s' f_y
\]
\[
A_s = \frac{.85 f'_c b a}{f_y} + A_s'
\]
---
## 9. **Relate \( a \) to \( M_n \)**
Total moment capacity:
\[
M_n = .85 f'_c b a (d - \frac{a}{2}) + A_s' f_y (d - d')
\]
Set \( M_n = 5,500,000 \) in-lb. This is a nonlinear equation in \( a \). We'll solve by iteration.
Let’s denote:
- \( b = 16 \) in
- \( d = 27 \) in
- \( d' = 3 \) in
- \( f'_c = 500 \) psi
- \( f_y = 40,000 \) psi
- \( A_s' = 2.00 \) in\(^2\)
Let’s try \( a = 4 \) in (initial guess).
\[
C_c = .85 \times 500 \times 16 \times 4 = .85 \times 500 \times 64 = .85 \times 320,000 = 272,000~\text{lb}
\]
\[
M_{c} = C_c \times (d - a/2) = 272,000 \times (27 - 2) = 272,000 \times 25 = 6,800,000~\text{in-lb}
\]
\[
M_{s'} = 80,000 \times (27 - 3) = 80,000 \times 24 = 1,920,000~\text{in-lb}
\]
But for moment, **compression steel acts in opposite direction**. The total moment is:
\[
M_n = C_c(d - a/2) + F_s'(d - d')
\]
But in the ACI approach, the *net* moment capacity is:
\[
M_n = .85 f'_c b a (d - a/2) + A_s' f_y (d - d')
\]
Plugging in \( a = 4 \) in:
\[
M_n = 272,000 \times 25 + 80,000 \times 24 = 6,800,000 + 1,920,000 = 8,720,000~\text{in-lb}
\]
But this is much higher than needed (\( 5,500,000 \)). Let's try a smaller \( a \).
Try \( a = 2.5 \) in:
\[
C_c = .85 \times 500 \times 16 \times 2.5 = .85 \times 500 \times 40 = .85 \times 200,000 = 170,000~\text{lb}
\]
\[
M_n = 170,000 \times (27 - 1.25) + 80,000 \times 24 = 170,000 \times 25.75 + 1,920,000 = 4,377,500 + 1,920,000 = 6,297,500~\text{in-lb}
\]
Still high. Try \( a = 2 \) in:
\[
C_c = .85 \times 500 \times 16 \times 2 = .85 \times 500 \times 32 = .85 \times 160,000 = 136,000~\text{lb}
\]
\[
M_n = 136,000 \times (27 - 1) + 1,920,000 = 136,000 \times 26 + 1,920,000 = 3,536,000 + 1,920,000 = 5,456,000~\text{in-lb}
\]
Very close to required \( 5,500,000 \). Try \( a = 2.1 \):
\[
C_c = .85 \times 500 \times 16 \times 2.1 = .85 \times 500 \times 33.6 = .85 \times 168,000 = 142,800~\text{lb}
\]
\[
M_n = 142,800 \times (27 - 1.05) + 1,920,000 = 142,800 \times 25.95 + 1,920,000 = 3,704,460 + 1,920,000 = 5,624,460~\text{in-lb}
\]
Too high. Try \( a = 2.05 \):
\[
C_c = .85 \times 500 \times 16 \times 2.05 = .85 \times 500 \times 32.8 = .85 \times 164,000 = 139,400~\text{lb}
\]
\[
M_n = 139,400 \times (27 - 1.025) + 1,920,000 = 139,400 \times 25.975 + 1,920,000 = 3,621,215 + 1,920,000 = 5,541,215~\text{in-lb}
\]
That's very close to our target (\( 5,500,000 \)).
---
## 10. **Compute Required Tension Steel \( A_s \)**
\[
A_s = \frac{.85 f'_c b a}{f_y} + A_s'
\]
\[
A_s = \frac{.85 \times 500 \times 16 \times 2.05}{40,000} + 2.00
\]
\[
= \frac{.85 \times 500 \times 32.8}{40,000} + 2.00
\]
\[
= \frac{.85 \times 164,000}{40,000} + 2.00
\]
\[
= \frac{139,400}{40,000} + 2.00
\]
\[
= 3.485 + 2.00 = 5.485~\text{in}^2
\]
---
## 11. **Number of #9 Bars Required in Tension**
Each #9 bar area = 1.00 in².
\[
\text{Number of bars} = \frac{5.485}{1.00} = 5.485
\]
Use **6 #9 bars** (always round up).
---
## 12. **Summary**
### **Final Answer**
- **Provide 6 #9 bars** for tension reinforcement (\( A_s = 6.00~\text{in}^2 \))
- **Provide 2 #9 bars** for compression reinforcement (\( A_s' = 2.00~\text{in}^2 \)) (already specified)
### **Check: Provided Area**
\[
A_s (\text{provided}) = 6.00~\text{in}^2
\]
\[
A_s (\text{required}) = 5.485~\text{in}^2
\]
Safe.
---
## **Bar Layout Suggestion**
- Place 6 #9 bars in tension zone (bottom layer)
- Place 2 #9 bars in compression zone (at 3" effective depth)
- Ensure adequate spacing and cover per ACI requirements
---
## **Summary Table**
| Reinforcement | Number of Bars | Bar Size | Area (in²) |
|---------------|:--------------:|:--------:|:----------:|
| Tension | 6 | #9 | 6.00 |
| Compression | 2 | #9 | 2.00 |
---
## **References**
- ACI 318-19, Table 9.5(a): Bar Areas
- ACI 318-19, Ch. 22: Flexural and Axial Strength
---
**[Note: Always check minimum and maximum reinforcement and detailing per code. This calculation is for the main flexural requirement only.]**