Give step-by-step solution with explanation and final answer:Which increment should be examined first in incremental rate of return analysis, if MARR = 11.5%? I From 0 [510000 [37.500 [510000 [55000 Annual 1,843 1,494 11,955 779 benefit O D-A O AB O B-C O AC
Question:
Give step-by-step solution with explanation and final answer:
Which increment should be examined first in incremental rate of return analysis, if MARR =
11.5%?
I
From 0 [510000 [37.500 [510000 [55000
Annual 1,843 1,494 11,955 779
benefit
O D-A
O AB
O B-C
O AC
This is AI generated Response.
Asked by: mayank
Created at: 2025-08-30 18:55:32
Asked by: mayank
Created at: 2025-08-30 18:55:32
Final Answer:
Rendered
Raw Text
Did you like this answer?
Let's solve the problem step by step:
### Step 1: **Order the Alternatives by First Cost**
Incremental analysis is performed by ranking the alternatives in order of increasing initial (first) cost:
- Do-nothing: $0
- D: $5,000
- B: $7,500
- A: $10,000
- C: $10,000
### Step 2: **Eliminate Dominated Alternatives**
If two alternatives have the same cost, the one with the higher benefit or higher ROR is preferred. Here, A and C both have a first cost of $10,000:
- A: Annual benefit = $1,843, ROR = 13%
- C: Annual benefit = $1,955, ROR = 14.5%
So, **A is dominated by C** and should be eliminated.
Now, the order is:
- Do-nothing: $0
- D: $5,000
- B: $7,500
- C: $10,000
### Step 3: **Select First Increment for Analysis**
Incremental analysis starts with the lowest-cost alternative and moves up. We examine the increment between each pair to find the first one to analyze.
- Compare D with Do-nothing, but D's ROR (9.0%) is less than MARR (11.5%) so D is not attractive.
- Next, compare B with D:
- First cost difference = $7,500 - $5,000 = $2,500
- Increment = B - D
So, the **first increment to be examined is D-A, but A is eliminated.**
Next, we check D-B.
### Step 4: **Which Increment to Examine First?**
So, the correct increment to examine first is **D-B**.
However, since D's ROR < MARR, eliminate D and move to the next two lowest cost alternatives:
- B and C.
So, **B-C** is the first increment to be examined.
---
## **Final Answer**
**B-C**
This matches the option:
- **B-C** (Correct choice)
---
### **Explanation**
- List alternatives by increasing cost.
- Eliminate dominated alternatives (A is dominated by C).
- Start with the lowest two alternatives above MARR.
- D's ROR is below MARR, so skip D and compare B and C.
**Therefore, the correct answer is:**
> **B-C**
📢 Instructions:
- Ask anything relatd to above question only.
- For new Question goto :
VIPSolutions