Question:
Give step-by-step solution with explanation and final answer: Q2: Pure liquid species A and B are for practical purposes immiscible in one another.
A third liquid C' is soluble in both A and B. One mole of each of liquids A, B
and C are shaken together to form an equilibrium mixture of two liquid phases:
an a-phase containing species A and C, and a 5-phase containing species B and
C. Let the excess molar Gibbs free energies of the phases at the temperature
of the experiment be
E
a _pszaze ama ©), = 0.8 zp 7
7a Ea or th wc
1
EE
(a) Let ng be the mole number of species C in the a-phase. What are the
activity coefficients of species C' of two phases in terms of n.?
(b) Based on the phase equilibrium of species C', what are the mole fractions
of species C in the a and § phases?
(¢) What is the minimum work (in units of RT) required to separate the
mixture back into the three pure species?
Did you like this answer?
👍 0
👎 0
Let's solve the problem **step by step**:
---
## **Given**
- Pure liquids A and B: Immiscible
- C is soluble in A and B.
- 1 mole each of A, B C (total 3 moles- Equilibrium Two liquid phases:
- **α-phase**: A + C
- **β-phase**: B + C
- Excess molar Gibbs free energies:
\[
\left(\frac{g^E}{RT}\right)_\alpha = .4\, x_A x_C
\]
\[
\left(\frac{g^E}{RT}\right)_\beta = .8\, x_B x_C
\]
---
## **(a) Activity Coefficients of C**
Let:
- \( n_C^\alpha \): moles of C in α-phase
- \( n_C^\beta \): moles of C in β-phase
In each phase:
- α-phase: contains A and C (moles: \( n_A^\alpha, n_C^\alpha \))
- β-phase: contains B and C (moles: \( n_B^\beta, n_C^\beta \))
**Mole fractions in α-phase:**
\[
x_A^\alpha = \frac{n_A^\alpha}{n_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha},\quad x_C^\alpha = \frac{n_C^\alpha}{n_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha}
\]
**Mole fractions in β-phase:**
\[
x_B^\beta = \frac{n_B^\beta}{n_B^\beta + n_C^\beta},\quad x_C^\beta = \frac{n_C^\beta}{n_B^\beta + n_C^\beta}
\]
**Activity coefficient (Margules model):**
\[
g^E = RT\, x_i x_C A
\]
For α-phase: \( A = .4 \), for β-phase: \( A = .8 \)
\[
\ln \gamma_C^\alpha = \frac{\partial (g^E/RT)}{\partial n_C^\alpha}
\]
But with Margules-type excess free energy:
\[
\ln \gamma_C^\alpha = .4\, x_A^\alpha
\]
\[
\ln \gamma_C^\beta = .8\, x_B^\beta
\]
**So, the activity coefficients:**
\[
\boxed{
\ln \gamma_C^\alpha = .4 \left(\frac{n_A^\alpha}{n_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha}\right)
}
\]
\[
\boxed{
\ln \gamma_C^\beta = .8 \left(\frac{n_B^\beta}{n_B^\beta + n_C^\beta}\right)
}
\]
---
## **(b) Phase Equilibrium Condition**
At equilibrium, the chemical potential of C must be equal in both phases:
\[
\mu_C^\alpha = \mu_C^\beta
\]
\[
\mu_C^* + RT \ln x_C^\alpha + RT \ln \gamma_C^\alpha = \mu_C^* + RT \ln x_C^\beta + RT \ln \gamma_C^\beta
\]
\[
\ln x_C^\alpha + \ln \gamma_C^\alpha = \ln x_C^\beta + \ln \gamma_C^\beta
\]
\[
x_C^\alpha \gamma_C^\alpha = x_C^\beta \gamma_C^\beta
\]
Substitute the expressions from part (a):
\[
x_C^\alpha \exp\left[.4 x_A^\alpha\right] = x_C^\beta \exp\left[.8 x_B^\beta\right]
\]
Let:
- \( n_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha = n^\alpha \)
- \( n_B^\beta + n_C^\beta = n^\beta \)
Mass balances:
- \( n_A^\alpha + n_A^\beta = 1 \) (but A only in α: \( n_A^\beta = \implies n_A^\alpha = 1 \))
- \( n_B^\alpha + n_B^\beta = 1 \) (B only in β: \( n_B^\alpha = \implies n_B^\beta = 1 \))
- \( n_C^\alpha + n_C^\beta = 1 \)
So,
- \( n^\alpha = 1 + n_C^\alpha \)
- \( n^\beta = 1 + n_C^\beta \)
So,
\[
x_A^\alpha = \frac{1}{1 + n_C^\alpha}, \quad x_C^\alpha = \frac{n_C^\alpha}{1 + n_C^\alpha}
\]
\[
x_B^\beta = \frac{1}{1 + n_C^\beta}, \quad x_C^\beta = \frac{n_C^\beta}{1 + n_C^\beta}
\]
Now substitute into equilibrium condition:
\[
\left( \frac{n_C^\alpha}{1 + n_C^\alpha} \right) \exp \left[ .4 \frac{1}{1 + n_C^\alpha} \right] = \left( \frac{n_C^\beta}{1 + n_C^\beta} \right) \exp \left[ .8 \frac{1}{1 + n_C^\beta} \right]
\]
with \( n_C^\alpha + n_C^\beta = 1 \).
This **implicit equation** can be solved numerically for \( n_C^\alpha \), \( n_C^\beta \).
---
## **(c) Minimum Work to Separate Mixture**
Minimum work (reversible separation) is equal to the **decrease in Gibbs free energy** (mixing):
\[
W_{min} = \Delta G_{mix}
\]
Where:
\[
\Delta G_{mix} = RT \left[ \sum_{i,ph} n_i^{ph} \ln x_i^{ph} + n^{ph} \frac{g^E}{RT} \right]
\]
Sum over all components and both phases.
**For this problem:**
- α-phase: \( n_A^\alpha = 1 \), \( n_C^\alpha \)
- β-phase: \( n_B^\beta = 1 \), \( n_C^\beta = 1 - n_C^\alpha \)
So:
\[
\Delta G_{mix}/RT =
n_A^\alpha \ln x_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha \ln x_C^\alpha + (n_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha) \cdot .4 x_A^\alpha x_C^\alpha
\]
\[
+ n_B^\beta \ln x_B^\beta + n_C^\beta \ln x_C^\beta + (n_B^\beta + n_C^\beta) \cdot .8 x_B^\beta x_C^\beta
\]
Plug the values from (b) into this formula for the final answer.
---
## **Summary Table**
| Part | Formula/Expression |
|------|-------------------|
| (a) | \( \ln \gamma_C^\alpha = .4 x_A^\alpha \), \( \ln \gamma_C^\beta = .8 x_B^\beta \) |
| (b) | \( x_C^\alpha \exp(.4 x_A^\alpha) = x_C^\beta \exp(.8 x_B^\beta) \), with \( n_C^\alpha + n_C^\beta = 1 \) |
| (c) | \( \Delta G_{mix}/RT = \) (see above, sum over both phases) |
---
## **Final Answers**
1. **Activity coefficients:**
\[
\boxed{
\ln \gamma_C^\alpha = .4 \left(\frac{1}{1 + n_C^\alpha}\right)
}
\]
\[
\boxed{
\ln \gamma_C^\beta = .8 \left(\frac{1}{1 + n_C^\beta}\right)
}
\]
2. **Mole fractions:** Solve numerically:
\[
\left( \frac{n_C^\alpha}{1 + n_C^\alpha} \right) \exp \left[ .4 \frac{1}{1 + n_C^\alpha} \right] = \left( \frac{n_C^\beta}{1 + n_C^\beta} \right) \exp \left[ .8 \frac{1}{1 + n_C^\beta} \right]
\]
with \( n_C^\alpha + n_C^\beta = 1 \).
3. **Minimum work (in units of \( RT \)):**
\[
\Delta G_{mix}/RT = \Big[ n_A^\alpha \ln x_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha \ln x_C^\alpha + (n_A^\alpha + n_C^\alpha) \cdot .4 x_A^\alpha x_C^\alpha \Big] + \Big[ n_B^\beta \ln x_B^\beta + n_C^\beta \ln x_C^\beta + (n_B^\beta + n_C^\beta) \cdot .8 x_B^\beta x_C^\beta \Big]
\]
---
**Numerical values** can be found by solving the equation in (b). If you want to see the numerical solution, let me know!